Five Levels of Leadership

In my blog for this month, I wanted to share with you concepts from a book that I am currently re-reading.  Given that time at work is often lengthy, and time with family is precious, to devote time to reading is something I consciously have to commit to and, in that context, to “re-read” something is an indication that either (a) I feel I missed something first time around, (b) its contents need re-visiting in the light of the circumstances I am working in at that time or (c) both (a) and (b)!

I first read John Maxwell’s “Five Levels of Leadership” last year as I prepared to make the step away from direct school leadership in my capacity as Principal at John Taylor High School, and become exclusively CEO of John Taylor Multi-Academy Trust.  I’ve read one of his early works “The 21 Irrefutable Laws of Leadership” and found it a valuable summary and guide, and so became drawn to this book as it seemed to chime with my situation.

Below you can see the five levels:

Maxwell profiles the opportunities, skills sets, and drawbacks of operating on each level, and enables the reader to self- and peer-assess where they reside within the hierarchy.  As I reflected on this personally, there was also an inescapable need to consider the leaders I have worked for and alongside – from the truly inspirational to the utterly positional!

In a survey conducted several years ago, Hay McBer indicated that school leadership was attributable for 81% of a school’s success or otherwise.  With it being of such importance, we all owe it to our schools and their communities to be the best we can be, and encourage others to be the best they can be too.

I would recommend this to anyone interested in charting their own leadership journey – past, present and future – and to all who see leadership, as Maxwell describes it, as “an opportunity to serve, as opposed to turf to be guarded.”

Thanks for reading.

It’s the most wonderful time of the year!

As we approach Christmas, I wanted to share a few words with you about imagination. I was drawn to this theme for my latest blog for two reasons:

First, I was asked to say a few words to the school leavers from John Taylor High School at their Post-16 Presentation Evening this coming week, and I was drawn to look at some of the words I said to them in an assembly when they started at the school seven years ago. Speaking to them about seizing the opportunities ahead, I shared with them an anonymous quotation: “The young are not bound by the prudence brought by experience. Because of this, they attempt the impossible – and they achieve it, generation after generation.” I believe that this is very true, and as a history teacher I also regard this as borne out by numerous examples throughout the ages.

Second, Christmas is a time of year where imagination runs riot for all of us. Again, this is because children are at the heart of it. The author Christopher Moore wrote that “Children see magic because they look for it.” Watching the latest Star Wars film with my twelve-year-old son last week, I could see that he was totally immersed in a story “a long time ago, in a galaxy far, far away” in a way that made me truly envious. Watching children pretend, role play, and problem solve in our schools, its clear the important part imagination plays in their development. It’s a privilege for me to spend time with fantastic teachers and leaders in our schools who cherish and nurture the imagination of the children they educate and care for. Like the most talented people always do, they make it look easy – but I know just how much planning and expertise goes into making such experiences both fun and meaningful for our children.

But back to my forthcoming speech. My message to John Taylor’s amazing Post-16 students, now a few months into university or work, is to hang on to their imaginations for dear life. We know that the greatest ideas come from the imagination: inventions, art, literature, discoveries. Imagination is at the heart of creativity, and creativity is at the heart of every society’s progress. Beyond this, we also all know the value that imagination can bring when we look to escape, even for a brief time, our own reality. Sometimes life isn’t what we want it to be, and we aren’t who we’d like to be. The artist Francis Bacon wrote that “Imagination was given to man to compensate him for what he is not; a sense of humour to console him for what he is.” Our alumni will do well to bear this in mind throughout their lives.

Finally, our imagination helps us to envisage things beyond our immediate experience. It provides us with opportunities to consider our world and those who inhabit it differently. We know that rigidity and intolerance are at the centre of so many of the world’s problems. Novelist Graham Greene wrote that “Hate is a lack of imagination.”, and I think he’s right. Again, the history teacher in me would argue that centuries of human suffering bears this out.

Children who lose the ability to imagine therefore lose something hugely precious. It’s the role of parents, and schools, and society to ensure that our children keep dreaming, keep imagining better and more exciting possibilities for themselves and their world. In a time where the focus of the curriculum has moved from skills to knowledge, there is an argument to be made that if education is ‘to replace an empty mind with an open one’ as I believe it is, we need to ensure sufficient opportunities are presented to our children to use their imaginations to the full. We won’t see the direct outcomes of this in school performance tables, but we will in the character of the next generation and the improvements they make to the world they have inherited from us.


Thanks for reading.